The Pain of Electricity (AC versus DC)

Haven’t you always wanted to know which one hurts more (AC or DC)? You don’t have to guess anymore:

Again, don’t try to shock yourselves at home.

Through all my years of being shocked, I somehow came to the understanding that AC (Alternating Current) hurts more than DC (Direct Current). Then somebody, which I don’t remember who, told me that the body has capacitive properties and lets the AC electricity through better. I don’t know how true that statement is, but from experience it somehow makes sense. If you hold on to a 50V DC voltage with dry hands, you won’t feel it as I experienced. But as soon as you switch the same voltage on and off at high speeds, such as 60Hz, it will shock you badly.

What I said in the video is true: if you want to feel the electricity pain, just get a 9V battery and put it on your tongue for a short period of time. Don’t worry, that’s harmless. But don’t go any higher in voltage.

A funny story: telephone lines carry around 48V of DC when not loaded. Once, we had moved into a brand new apartment and the phone lines where not connected. I was going through the phone box to find our line that was supposed to be live and couldn’t find it. One guy came in and said I’ll find it for you, and started putting those phone line pairs on his tongue. Then when he received a huge shock, he said: “Here is your line” and I said thanks! I must be ashamed of myself that I can’t take it more than 12 volts!

Now as I show in my video, the AC seems to hurt at RMS levels half of the DC. But you should know that RMS means the effective AC voltage, meaning that from power consumption point of view an AC signal with specific RMS value is equal to the same value DC signal. But the actual peak of the AC voltage is the RMS value times 1.41. So a 6.5V RMS means that it is oscillating around 0V with 9.16V peaks in a sine wave form.

I have been shocked with 220V AC, 50Hz back in Iran, and also with 110V AC, 60Hz in Canada, and I should say they both hurt equally bad. I expected the 220V to hurt twice the 110V, but it didn’t feel that different. Either my pain sensor was saturated on both and didn’t feel the difference, or the 10Hz extra of the 110V compensates for its lower level.

30 thoughts on “The Pain of Electricity (AC versus DC)

  1. Great topic. I needs to spend some time
    learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for magnificent information I was looking for this info for my mission. Keep up good work.

  2. Paulo Coelho‘s The Alchemist is the
    tale of Santiago, an Andalusian guard boy material to wander via the Spanish industries and towns with his faithful flcok
    till a reoccuring desire regarding discovering his treasure at the Pyramids of Egypt rousts him
    from complacency. In trying to understand his dream, Santiago
    runs into a wise old man that calls himself Melchizedek, the
    King of Salem, that sets the kid off on a quest to find his Personal Tale:

  3. I have a electric plainer jointer which is 120v ac 12.5amp 60hrts however my home power supply is only 110v dc 50hrts what can i do to make my machine work ?
    oh yes my machine also says it has 1 horse power continuous something, must be a very small horse. please help.

  4. This is why Iranians should not leave Iran. Once they breathe the sweet air of freedom (yes, even in Canada), THEY GO CRAZY!!!!!

    Keep up the good work!

  5. Another awesome video. I would never in a million years do what you did here; I seriously dislike electric shocks. I’ve shocked myself (unintentionally) with everything from 220V/60Hz to 9V DC. The 220 hit made my arm numb for about 15 minutes. I think your experience with 220 may have been due to a poor return path.
    Any thoughts on 3 phase power and pain/risk of electrocution? I am morbidly curious; please don’t feel the need to test it personally.
    I also love the social commentary!

  6. Did you get such a flexible tongue by ac-tongue dancing or by birth ?
    Anyway, your video’s are great, hilarious and educational, as autodidact I unfortunately had to learn a lot by experience :)
    For one thing I only needed one lesson, never get distracted while soldering, firmly picking up a hot iron at the wrong end really hurts…

  7. Love your article, though probably not wise to suggest 9V batteries are harmless. There’s a couple of deaths a year from 9V batteries, Google it! :)

    • I did a bit of searching and didn’t find anything… yet. I believe it’s a myth. You can’t die from a 9 battery unless you stick the voltage right into your body on a critical nerve path. If a 9V tiny battery kills, I expect more people die from 12V high power car batteries. Will you send me a link to a death from a 9V battery?

  8. Pingback: » Guys tests AC and DC current to see which hurts more Fuzzy Hypothesis Online

  9. Did you notice the difference in taste between positive terminal and negative one?

    When doing this with < 9V as a kid, I rapidly learned to differentiate polarity by taste. The skill persists to this day.

    Funny video. Nice humor take on the whole thing.

  10. Man! Stop doing what you’re doing! You have been “bitten” by 110V and 220V AC already! Are you going around the globe, “testing” the flavor of electricity? :-)
    Seriously now this was a great article, just how it’s supposed to be: informative and funny! Keep up the good work but please don’t kill yourself in the process…
    I work a lot with valve amplifiers and even though I haven’t been “bitten” yet, I fear the time I will have 600V DC across my body. As always the “one handed electrician” practice is a good idea if you don’t want to have all this current across your heart. It will put it out of comission as fast as you can imagine.

  11. Pingback: AC vs DC human pain test | Make, Electronics projects, electronic Circuits, DIY projects, Microcontroller Projects -

  12. Pingback: AC vs DC human pain test - RaspberryPiBoards

  13. Pingback: rndm(mod) » AC vs DC human pain test

  14. Really great video!

    One of my first memories is the shock of a 220 V AC @ 50 Hz. I was about three years old, and my parents were rebuilding some panels in the house and left a socket unprotected, which was obviously very interesting for a curious little boy. :-) Since then, I’ve been shocked quite a few times, most recently by a 50 V cable TV signal. Why on earth do they do that?

    Nowadays, it is rare, though, since I started to learn about how much heat high currents through thin wires generate, and having seen that in a lab kinda gives you a hint that if you have the hand of a theoritician (like me), you ought to stay away from practical matters. :-)

  15. I inadvertently applied 2 KV @ about 5 mA AC when the hipot tester proved to be faulty; I thought my shoulder-blades were going to slam together. Ouch. Glad I was on the ground because it was a shorter fall.

    Love the safety push in your video work; humour rather than pedantry.

  16. Pingback: Corriente alterna vs. corriente continua, qué es la electricidad mostrada en un experimento poco convencional | Woratek - Tecnología que te ayuda

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>